Row of small local storefronts at dusk with soft light trails resting on different shops, representing how AI answers change from search to search

How Does AI Decide Which Local Businesses to Recommend?

November 05, 2026•10 min read

Picture a homeowner with a leaking kitchen faucet on a Sunday afternoon. She asks her phone, “Who's a good plumber near me?” and gets three names. Her neighbor asks the same question an hour later and gets three different names. Same street, same question, different answers. (That's an illustration, not a study.)

One of those plumbers did nothing different between the two searches. He just wasn't in the answer the second time.

Nobody outside the AI companies knows exactly how these tools choose, but studies show where they look. In a BrightLocal study of about 200,000 local searches, business websites made up 42% of the sources AI cited and your Google Business Profile made up 28.5%. Yext's separate research also found websites were the biggest source (BrightLocal, 2026; Yext, 2025).

In plain terms, your Google Business Profile (GBP) is the free listing that appears when people search for your business on Google Search and Maps. You may still hear it called GMB, its former name.

I'm Paul, and I get local businesses found, chosen, and followed up with. This is the first piece in a series on how AI tools find and recommend local businesses. It covers the big picture: where AI looks, why its answers move around, and what to do about it today.

Are Customers Really Asking AI for Local Recommendations?

A lot of them are. In BrightLocal's 2026 survey of 1,002 US adults, 45% use ChatGPT and other generative AI tools for local business recommendations, up from 6% the year before (BrightLocal, 2026). SOCi's 2026 survey of more than 1,000 US consumers found something similar with different wording: 52% used an AI tool to find a local business in the last 30 days (SOCi, 2026). For a wider view, Pew Research Center's 2026 survey of 5,119 US adults found about half use AI chatbots, and about four in ten use them to search for information (Pew Research Center, 2026).

But asking is not the same as buying. In Yext's 2026 survey of 3,848 adults worldwide, only 5% went straight from an AI answer to a purchase. After an AI recommendation, 49% visited the business's website, 42% clicked through to the AI's sources, and 28% looked for reviews (Yext, 2026). SOCi found that 81% of consumers take some kind of verification step before contacting a business an AI recommended (SOCi, 2026). And 97% of AI users in BrightLocal's survey said they sometimes double-check AI recommendations against real reviews (BrightLocal, 2026).

BrightLocal sells local SEO tools, Yext sells listings software, and SOCi sells local marketing software. All three surveys are self-reported, and Yext says its figures are directional. Pew is independent, but the part of its report I read doesn't ask about local businesses. So the numbers differ, but they point the same way: the AI answer is often a first stop, not the last one. People still check you out.

Where Does AI Get Its Local Business Information?

Two separate vendor studies point the same way on one thing: business websites are the biggest source, the kind of site you control. BrightLocal reviewed about 200,000 localized searches across ChatGPT, Google AI Mode, and Google AI Overviews, and about 1.9 million citations. Business websites made up 42% of them (BrightLocal, 2026). Yext analyzed 6.8 million citations from ChatGPT, Gemini, and Perplexity. Websites made up 44% and listings made up 42% (Yext, 2025). Its 2026 follow-up of 155.5 million citations found that about four in five pointed to a website or a listing (Yext citation study, 2026). Yext's samples come from brands tracked on its own platform, so they may not match a one-location business.

Your Google Business Profile matters, but one number rests on one study. BrightLocal found it made up 28.5% of all citations, by far the most important source on AI Mode and AI Overviews, and hardly used by ChatGPT (BrightLocal, 2026). Yext doesn't break out Google Business Profile, so that percentage has no second source yet. Whitespark's guide to Google's AI Mode says its business summaries and star ratings are pulled from Business Profiles or other sources (Whitespark, 2026), and Google's own page lists keeping your Business Profile information up to date (Google, 2025).

Directories show up, but which ones varies. Yelp made up about 9.5% of citations in BrightLocal's study (BrightLocal, 2026). In Yext's 2026 data, MapQuest and TripAdvisor were cited more often than Yelp among third-party sites (Yext citation study, 2026).

BrightLocal sells the AI tracking tool its study is based on, and its page gives slightly different totals for searches and locations in two places, so I'm using rounded numbers. Yext sells the listings products its studies recommend. Neither study measured whether reviews change who gets recommended, so I won't claim they do.

Why Does AI Give a Different Answer Every Time?

This is the part most owners don't expect. When BrightLocal repeated the same local searches, the lists of businesses overlapped only 20% to 33% on average: 23% for ChatGPT, 21% for AI Mode, and 33% for AI Overviews (BrightLocal, 2026).

A separate study found the same pattern outside local search. SparkToro's Rand Fishkin had 600 volunteers run 12 prompts through ChatGPT, Claude, and Google's AI a combined 2,961 times. ChatGPT and Google's AI gave the same list of brands fewer than 1 time in 100, almost never in the same order, and lists ranged from 2 or 3 recommendations to 10 or more (SparkToro, 2026). That study wasn't about local businesses, isn't peer-reviewed, and its author discloses a tie to an AI tracking startup, so I read it as direction, not proof. Whitespark's guide says the same about Google's AI Mode: each user may see different results for the same query (Whitespark, 2026).

In my view, that means one search proves very little. If you ask once and don't see your name, you haven't learned that you're invisible. And if you do see it, you haven't learned that you're safe. The next piece in this series goes deeper on this.

Do You Need Special AI Optimization?

For Google's AI features, Google says no. Its page on AI features says there are no additional requirements to appear in AI Overviews or AI Mode, and no special optimizations or new files, markup, or schema are necessary. It says SEO best practices remain relevant, and it lists keeping your Business Profile information up to date among them (Google, 2025). That page was last updated in December 2025, so Google may have changed it since.

Google's page covers Google's own features only, not ChatGPT's.

What you can control is accuracy. SOCi's survey found that 67% of consumers who use AI tools say they've been given wrong information about a local business at least once, and 30% say bad information caused a real inconvenience (SOCi, 2026). That's a good reason to make sure your hours, phone number, and address are right everywhere.

One Thing to Check Right Now

On your phone, ask ChatGPT and Google's AI Mode the question a customer would ask, such as “best [your service] near [your town].” Ask it twice, a few minutes apart. Write down whether your business is named either time, and which websites the answer lists as sources.

Then open your own Google Business Profile and check that your hours, phone number, address, and services are right.

What You Just Checked, and What You Didn't

That check gives you a snapshot from one phone at one moment. It doesn't show how you appear across your whole service area, how it changes over weeks, or who is being named instead of you. BrightLocal itself recommends tracking your AI presence over a period of time (BrightLocal, 2026). That takes ongoing attention, and it's where having someone do it for you makes a real difference.

How We Handle This for Clients

For clients, we keep the Google Business Profile, the website, and the business listings accurate and telling the same story, because those are among the places AI tools pull from. The goal is that however a customer asks, they find the same correct information about you.

Frequently Asked Questions

How does AI decide which local businesses to recommend?

The AI companies don't publish a formula. In a BrightLocal study of about 200,000 local searches, Google Business Profile made up 28.5% of citations and business websites made up 42% (BrightLocal, 2026). Yext's separate study also found websites were the largest source, at 44% of citations (Yext, 2025).

Do I need special optimization or schema to show up in Google's AI answers?

Google says there are no additional requirements, no special optimization, and no special schema needed for AI Overviews or AI Mode, and that SEO best practices still apply (Google, 2025).

Does ChatGPT use my Google Business Profile?

BrightLocal found Google Business Profile was hardly used as a source by ChatGPT, but was the most important source for Google AI Mode and AI Overviews (BrightLocal, 2026).

Why does AI recommend different businesses each time I ask?

In BrightLocal's local study, repeat searches overlapped only 20% to 33% on average (BrightLocal, 2026), and SparkToro found the same kind of variation across industries (SparkToro, 2026). One search is a snapshot, not a ranking.

Here's the Plan

AI tools are becoming a real front door for local businesses, but the answers move around. Start with your own phone, check what shows up, and make sure the basics are right.

What you just checked is one snapshot. It can't show how you appear across your area. I'll run a scan and show you where your business ranks on Google Maps for the searches your customers are most likely to use. I'll also look over your profile and send you a plain-English report with what I find.

No contracts, no obligation, and it's yours to keep whether we ever work together or not.

SEE WHERE MY BUSINESS RANKS

If you'd rather talk it through first, book a free, no-pressure session with me.

Related reading: What Customers Check on Your Google Business Profile Before They Call and Do You Still Need a Website If Customers Find You on Google?.

This is the first piece in our series on how AI tools find and recommend local businesses. Coming next: Is Your Google Business Profile the Page AI Reads, Why AI Gives a Different Answer Every Time You Ask, Storefront or Service-Area Business: Does AI Treat You Differently, and Your Website and Directory Listings: What AI Cites Besides Your Profile.

Sources & Further Reading

Local AI Visibility Study, BrightLocal (published September 16, 2026); about 200,000 localized searches (vendor)

Nearly Half of Consumers are Asking AI for Business Recommendations, BrightLocal (published March 10, 2026), 1,002 US adults (vendor, self-reported)

AI Usage Surges 6X for Local Search, SOCi (published September 24, 2026); 2026 Local Discovery Index, more than 1,000 US consumers (vendor, self-reported)

Americans and AI 2026: Chatbots, Smart Devices and Views on Impact, Pew Research Center (June 17, 2026), 5,119 US adults

Yext 2026 Consumer Search Behaviors Report, 3,848 adults worldwide (vendor; self-reported; directional)

Yext Research: 86% of AI Citations Come from Brand-Managed Sources, Yext (October 9, 2025); 6.8 million citations (vendor)

With Location On, AI Cites the Sources That Know Places, Yext (July 2026); 155.5 million citations (vendor)

AIs are highly inconsistent when recommending brands or products, SparkToro (January 2026); 2,961 runs, not local-specific, not peer-reviewed

Whitespark's Guide to Google's AI Mode for Local Businesses, Whitespark (May 22, 2026; vendor)

AI features and your website, Google Search Central (last updated December 10, 2025)

Custom HTML/CSS/JavaScript
Paul Basile

Paul Basile

Paul is the founder of Get Local Visibility. He helps local business owners get found, get leads, and stop losing customers to fixable problems, no jargon, no sales pressure, just straight answers from someone who's spent real time inside the profiles, websites, and phone systems local businesses actually run on

Back to Blog